Affichage des articles dont le libellé est private. Afficher tous les articles
Affichage des articles dont le libellé est private. Afficher tous les articles

jeudi 13 juin 2013

The Supreme Court of Canada will hear Loyola High School

The Supreme Court of Canada will hear an appeal from a Catholic high school that wants to be exempted from teaching Quebec's ethics and religious culture program in a secular fashion.

Jesuit-run Loyola High School wants to be allowed to use its own course and teach it from a Catholic perspective.

The law allows for such an exemption where the alternative course is deemed by the minister of education to be equivalent to the provincial program.

The minister turned down the school's request, but the Superior Court of Quebec sided with the school and allowed the exemption.

The provincial appeal court, however, reversed that decision in a ruling last December.

As usual, the Supreme Court gave no reasons for its decision to hear the case.

See also

Bilingual text Loyola v. Monopoly of Education (appeal) / Texte bilingue Loyola c. le Monopole de l'Éducation (appel)

Loyola decision infringes on parental choices, says CCRL

Loyola has had a World Religions course for 25 years

Loyola High School asks the Supreme Court to hear the case

Loyola's principal Paul Donovan on ERC Court Case

Ethics and Religious Culture in Court (on Loyola High's website)

State: Loyola’s teachers have to pretend that the Catholic school was equally open to the idea that Jesus was a complete fraud

Quebec’s position smacks of totalitarianism. The Court of Appeal ruling should not, and hopefully will not stand.

Tommy Schnurmacher on Loyola High school

Our Loyola file (in English and French)





Soutenons les familles dans leurs combats juridiques (reçu fiscal pour tout don supérieur à 50 $)

lundi 10 décembre 2012

Vatican Radio : Catholic School in Quebec loses religious freedom case

ROME — A Catholic private school is considering petitioning the Supreme Court of Canada, after the Quebec Court of Appeal issued a decision obliging it to teach a state-imposed Ethics and Religious Culture course (ERC) at odds with Catholic teaching. The Quebec court issued its decision Dec. 4, overturning an earlier judgment of the Superior Court, which supported the request Loyola High School put to the education minister to teach the course objectives from a Catholic perspective. The Jesuit boys school, located in Montreal, has been battling the provincial government on this issue since 2008.


Marie Bourque, vice-president of the Catholic Parents Association of Quebec, said the decision infringes on the rights of parents to choose an education for their children in line with their faith and values and “to rely on the collaboration of confessional schools” to this end. The Catholic Civil Rights League also issued a comment in agreement.

Bourque described the ERC as a “totally superficial, folkloric and materialistic” program, which “forbids any chronological or historical teaching of religions.”

“It presents them as the fruit of the human mind,” she explained. “It’s all relativistic; there’s no absolute truth at all. So, moral and philosophical stands, which are atheistic, certainly sound more credible than any religion at all in this context.”

Both the Catholic Church and the UN Declaration of Human Rights state that parental rights in education are essential and must be upheld, she underlined.

“The responsibility belongs to (parents) to teach morals and religion. They can delegate it to whom they choose but it belongs absolutely to them in the first place,” she said.

Loyola High School first took legal action in 2008, when the education minister refused to grant equivalency to the school’s Morals and World Religions course. The minister argued that Loyola’s course is taught from a Catholic viewpoint, whereas the state course requires religions to be taught from a secular and religiously neutral perspective.


Listen to the interview by Laura Ieraci with Marie Bourque: RealAudioMP3


See also


Supreme Court — Break with Common Law Putting the Onus on Parents rather than the State(With sample activities and material used in ERC classes)





Soutenons les familles dans leurs combats juridiques (reçu fiscal pour tout don supérieur à 50 $)

jeudi 6 décembre 2012

Loyola decision infringes on parental choices, says CCRL

MONTREAL, QC December 6, 2012 – The Catholic Civil Rights League (CCRL) today commented on the decision of the Quebec Court of Appeal that requires Loyola High School, a private Catholic institution, to teach the province’s Ethics and Religious Culture (ERC) course. The school had asked to cover the course material in a religion program based on its Catholic perspective, a request which was upheld by the Quebec Superior Court but appealed by the province.

The Court of Appeal decision, issued December 4, declared that because Loyola’s course is Catholic in orientation, it could not be considered equivalent to the ERC program, because the ERC course was specifically designed to be religiously "neutral".

“With this decision, the Court of Appeal has seriously infringed upon the right of parents to direct the religious education of their children,” says League President Philip Horgan.

In 2008, the Education Minister at the time, Michelle Courchesne, refused to declare that the course in Morals and World Religions Loyola High School in Montreal was equivalent to ERC, arguing that the program offered by the school was given from a Catholic viewpoint whereas the ethics and religious culture approach must be "secular". The school took the case to Quebec's Superior Court. In June 2010, the Superior Court reversed the decision of the minister and the school was allowed to teach its substitute program as equivalent. The Court of Appeal has overturned that decision and upheld the original decision of the Minister of Education.

This decision creates a dilemma for Catholic parents in Quebec, who may seek to send their children to a private Catholic school to avail their children of an authentic moral and religious upbringing in accordance with their faith, a right recognized and guaranteed by several international treaties to which Canada is a party, and to which a robust understanding of the Charter of Rights would normally recognize.

In February, the Supreme Court of Canada decided in the case of S.L. that sufficient evidence would be needed to support a finding for an exemption from the ERC curriculum. Loyola produced the requests for exemption on behalf of its entire school community, supported by expert opinions on the merits of its program as compared to the Quebec ERC curriculum. The trial judge accepted that position, stating at one point that the Quebec government's position was verging on totalitarianism.

With this ruling, the Court of Appeal has chosen to overrule the trial judge's decision, which was based on extensive expert evidence, in favour of the ambitions of the Quebec government, which stated that its program was better suited for greater tolerance in society.

Quebec continues to engage in a grand social experiment, over the legitimate objections of religious parents.

The Association of Catholic Parents of Quebec (APCQ) deplores the fact that everywhere in Quebec, children 6 to 16 years will be introduced, through the ERC course, to a set of amalgamated religions, beliefs, myths and legends. The President of the APCQ, Jean Morse-Chevrier, who is also a Quebec director of the League, believes this teaching devalues religion in favour of a phenomenalist and relativistic approach. She says that the judgment gives more clout to a government that devalues the religious rights of its citizens and their institutions.

The CCRL hopes that the Supreme Court is invited to review its previous ruling on the ERC curriculum in the context of the Loyola experience.

About CCRL

Catholic Civil Rights League (www.ccrl.ca) assists in creating conditions within which Catholic teachings can be better understood, cooperates with other organizations in defending civil rights in Canada, and opposes defamation and discrimination against Catholics on the basis of their beliefs. CCRL was founded in 1985 as an independent lay organization and has chapters across Canada. The Catholic Civil Rights League is a Canadian non-profit organization entirely supported by the generosity of its members.

For further information:
Joanne McGarry, Executive Director, 416-466-8244; joanne.mcgarry@ccrl.ca


See also


Supreme Court — Break with Common Law Putting the Onus on Parents rather than the State (With sample activities and material used in ERC classes)




Soutenons les familles dans leurs combats juridiques (reçu fiscal pour tout don supérieur à 50 $)

mardi 21 février 2012

Prof. Paul Allen : debate far from over about Ethics and Religious Culture


Paul Allen, a professor of theology at Concordia University, says the legal matter is far from settled, because Loyola High School is challenging the contents of the provincially imposed coursework.


See also


Professor Douglas Farrow's "On the Ethics and Religious Culture Program" Report as Expert Witness in the Loyola High School vs. Ministry of Education court case.





Soutenons les familles dans leurs combats juridiques (reçu fiscal pour tout don supérieur à 50 $)

mardi 22 juin 2010

The Gazette welcomes the Loyola ruling

The Gazette's editorial in today's issue is favorable to Justice Dugré's ruling. Extract.


Loyola High's principal, Paul Donovan, assailed by reporters at yesterday's press conference.
The ruling, in a case brought by the private Catholic Loyola High School, is excellent news for those who believe in freedom of religion and in parental choice in education. However, the ruling sends the government, and society in general, back to Square One in the matter of teaching about religious tolerance and the equality of religions in the public sphere.

The ERC course, with its no-religion-is-more-right-that-any-other theme, was part of Quebec's too-often-panicky approach to the whole problem of accommodating and integrating religious and other minorities. There might well be a need to ensure that no Quebec schools are systematically producing religious bigots, but mandating this course was using far too big a hammer for the job. Loyola has given Montreal a steady stream of distinguished citizens; we haven't heard of any religious fanatics among them.

A strong majority of Loyola parents had asked that their children not be taught the mandatory ERC course, since it prevented the school from teaching from a Catholic perspective, which is after all the purpose of a Catholic school. When the government refused an exemption, Loyola's administration was emboldened to go to court. It has now won vindication for freedom of choice across the board: Other religious high schools will surely apply the ruling, and public schools will also have to grapple with the problem.

That's fine. This ill-conceived denial of religious orientation in the teaching of ethics won't be missed.




Soutenons les familles dans leurs combats juridiques (reçu fiscal pour tout don supérieur à 50 $)

samedi 19 juin 2010

Ruling slams Quebec approach. Attempt to impose secular focus on teaching compared to Spanish Inquisition

The Gazette of Montreal summarizes Justice Dugré's ruling:

A private Catholic school in west end Montreal has won a court ordered exemption from a provincial government order that it teach a controversial ethics and morality course within the boundaries established by Quebec's Education Dept.

And while the principal of Loyola High School says the Superior Court decision simply confirms what his institution has already been doing -examining other religious and ethical creeds through a Catholic perspective -the judge in the case was withering in his assessment of the Education Department's conduct in its dealings with the school, going so far as to compare the province's attempt to impose a secular focus on Loyola's teaching of the course to the intolerance of the Spanish Inquisition.

"In this age of the respect of fundamental rights, of tolerance, reasonable accommodation and multiculturalism, the attitude adopted by the (Education) minister, is surprising," wrote Judge Gerard Dugre in a 63-page judgment handed down yesterday. "Canadian democratic society is based on principles recognizing the supremacy of God and the primacy of the law -both of which benefit from constitutional protection.

"The obligation imposed on Loyola to teach the ethics and religious culture course in a lay fashion assumes a totalitarian character essentially equivalent to Galileo's being ordered by the Inquisition to deny the Copernican universe." Dugre ruled that by trying to compel Loyola High School, a Catholic institution founded in 1848, to adhere to rigidly secular teaching guidelines, the provincial government violated the school's freedom of religion as guaranteed by the Quebec Charter of Rights.

[...]

"What we had asked for was that all the objectives and all the material ... about world religions and ethical systems -which we had been doing anyway -be adjusted slightly," Loyola principal Paul Donovan told The Gazette last night, "And they told us ... that the minister's decision to say no was essentially because our approach was Catholic."

That approach, Donovan said, would have compelled Loyola teaching staff to treat certain ethical perspectives as being morally equivalent.

"If one student wanted to be a hedonist ... and another student took the perspective of being forgiving to others ... it could never be implied (during the teaching of that course) that one of those perspectives might be a better choice ... and for us, that would be problematic."

Loyola High School's victory yesterday might affect the approach taken by other parochial schools uneasy over the ethics course.





Soutenons les familles dans leurs combats juridiques (reçu fiscal pour tout don supérieur à 50 $)

mercredi 15 juillet 2009

Reportage en neuf langues sur l'affaire du collège Loyola contre le Monopole de l'Éducation du Québec



Le reportage de Télévision Sel + Lumière sur la cause opposant le collège Loyola au Gouvernement du Québec au sujet de l'imposition du cours d’Éthique et culture religieuse a été adapté par le service de nouvelles catholiques internationales H2ONews.

Il est disponible en ligne en 8 langues étrangères (en plus du français) dès aujourd’hui.

Italiano Español English Português Deutsch Magyar 中文 العربية