Affichage des articles dont le libellé est state. Afficher tous les articles
Affichage des articles dont le libellé est state. Afficher tous les articles

vendredi 14 décembre 2012

State: Loyola’s teachers have to pretend that the Catholic school was equally open to the idea that Jesus was a complete fraud

By Father Raymond J. de Souza

Perhaps the timing was Providential, if one is still permitted to say that at a Quebec high school. I came here to Loyola high school in Montreal to give a lecture on faith in our common life, only one day after the Quebec government had won an appellate court victory that, in effect, said there was not much room for faith at Loyola, unless the teachers here pretended it wasn’t true. Comforting the afflicted is one of the traditional tasks of both priests and journalists, so I was happy to be on hand.

My colleague Barbara Kay detailed the facts of the case yesterday in this space on Wednesday, indicating her agreement with the lower court judge that it is “totalitarian” to compel a private Jesuit high school to teach that, as between Christianity and say, witchcraft, there can be no considered judgment as to which view is to be proposed.

When Quebec secularized its schools more than a decade ago, it was decided to teach students about the realm of the spirit in a new course called Ethical and Religious Culture (ERC). The ERC curriculum requires teachers to maintain strict neutrality between all creeds, whether they appear on the extensive list in the curriculum or they are other perspectives the students might themselves introduce to the class. So the teacher would instruct the students that Christians believe that Jesus is divine, but that Muslims do not.

Happy to do so, Loyola said, noting that it already had been teaching world religions for some time. But, the Catholic school asked the ministry of the education, could we also teach that while Buddhists do not recognize Jesus as being divine, we do, being Catholics? The ministry said no, that Loyola’s teachers would have to pretend that the Catholic school was equally open to the idea that Jesus was a complete fraud rather than the sovereign Lord of all creation.

Loyola preferred neither to pretend nor to deny its faith, and went to court, arguing that the ERC mandate was not only a violation of religious liberty in principle, but practically absurd. Loyola won at the superior court, but has now lost at the appellate level. A Supreme Court appeal may be launched.

This is not an argument of public provision. Loyola is a private school. And, in any case, the ERC applies even to homeschoolers. Consider that: a Muslim mother who homeschools her children in order to better teach them the Islamic way of life would also have to teach them that being Muslim is no better than being an atheist.

Pope Benedict XVI sent his inaugural tweets yesterday. I half hoped he might send one to us: “Canada, good luck with the dictatorship of relativism!” For Joseph Ratzinger warned us about this on the day before he was elected pope, in an address to the college of cardinals:

“Today, having a clear faith based on the Creed of the Church is often labelled as fundamentalism. Whereas relativism, that is, letting oneself be ‘tossed here and there, carried about by every wind of doctrine’, seems the only attitude that can cope with modern times. We are building a dictatorship of relativism that does not recognize anything as definitive.”

When we hear about dictatorship in Canada, our initial response is to be skeptical. Surely not here! But what else to call a state mandate that dictates that Catholic schools — and every single religious believer in Quebec of any creed — must teach relativism pure and simple, namely that between two contradictory positions, both are equally true or equally false, or to put it more directly, equally nothing.

Loyola had its Christmas decorations up when I visited. I spoke in front of a large Christmas tree and nativity scene. Tonight, they are having their Christmas concert and, yes, they call it a “Christmas” concert. The poster features the Magi from the east. What are the teachers to say about all this if ERC is imposed upon them? That the Magi were not wise men but on a fool’s errand?

The Quebec government seems to believe religion is like the playful Santa Claus in the Loyola foyer, a mere seasonal decoration that few will miss. But the nativity scene in the heart of the school is not a decoration — it is a statement of faith. It won’t do to profess the faith in the centre of the school only to deny it in the classroom.

The Magi were searching for Jesus. They had to deal with King Herod. Today, those seeking for Jesus have instead the Quebec ministry of education and the appellate court. Be of good courage, Loyola!

See also:

Our Loyola file (French and English)

Our ethics file (English, most entries relate to ECR)




Soutenons les familles dans leurs combats juridiques (reçu fiscal pour tout don supérieur à 50 $)

jeudi 13 décembre 2012

Quebec’s position smacks of totalitarianism. The Court of Appeal ruling should not, and hopefully will not stand.

All must be accorded absolute respect, according to a draconian mandate from Quebec's education junta.


By Barbara Kay.

Until 2008, the curriculum of Montreal’s (private) Catholic Loyola High School included a course called “Morals and World Religions” (MWR). MWR taught students the basic history and tenets of other major religions from the Catholic perspective, which is presumably what the students’ parents were paying for.

Paul Donovan, principal of Loyola High School
in Montreal. Photo: G. Hughes for National Post
In 2008, however, Quebec introduced a province-wide program called Ethics and Religious Culture (ERC) running throughout elementary school, and all but one high school year. Every Quebec student — even the homeschooled — is obligated to take this state-composed program. And teachers, whatever their beliefs or religious affiliation, must teach it.

The ERC’s mandate is to introduce students to Quebec’s diversity of religions and cultures with “absolute respect for every religious position.” As a short perusal of ERC’s culturally relativistic texts makes clear, Wicca, Raëlism, aboriginal animism or even a student’s own invented religion are all accorded equal spiritual standing with Christianity. This is an untenable intellectual perspective, and obviously one that stands in opposition to Catholic teachings. Yet no child may be exempted on grounds that the ERC might negatively impact confidence in his own religion.

Loyola sought an institutional exemption, arguing that the school taught the same substantive knowledge as ERC in their MWR course. The ministry denied the request. Loyola pursued a legal challenge on Charter grounds of religious freedom. At trial, the Quebec attorney general contended that the Charter applies to individuals; religious corporations, such as a Jesuit school, he argued, are not entitled to freedom of religion.

The presiding lower court judge, Justice Dugré, disagreed with Quebec’s position. He ruled that the forced replacement of MRW would undermine Loyola’s own sense of identity and religious character, even stating that Quebec’s supersession of ERC over Loyola’s teaching commitments was “totalitarian in nature.”

But Quebec’s Court of Appeal then overturned the lower court’s ruling. Unless resolved otherwise by the Supreme Court, it means that a government can compel a faith community to jettison its driving beliefs in order to promote the state’s secular religion of multiculturalism; or indeed, in the future, to compel promotion of any other theory or belief the state may wish to substitute for a faith community’s convictions.

If the “Catholic perspective” mocked or refuted other routes to spiritual fulfilment, the Court of Appeal decision would be correct. On the contrary, though, the Catholic understanding of faith is far richer and more respectful of religion than that presented in the ERC, which comes at the subject from a secular perspective, and essentially ignores the whole concept of “faith” altogether.

To Quebec’s education ministry, religion is a cultural preference, not a deeply held core belief. For Catholics, on the other hand, everyone who is a Catholic or a member of another religious faith —or even atheistic — is respected as a spiritual pilgrim on a profound journey in pursuit of truth.

In view of its raison d’être, Loyola finds itself caught between the proverbial rock and hard place. As Douglas Farrow, professor of Christian Thought at McGill University and an expert witness in the case, put it to me: “Were the Loyola community to accede to this demand, it would not only be violating its conscience, but also allowing that the Court stands above its conscience … This it cannot do and remain Catholic in any meaningful sense.”

The stated objective of the ERC program is to “cultivate the recognition of others and pursuit of the common good.” Must the “recognition of others” preclude a special attachment to one’s own heritage?

As for “pursuit of the common good,” it was a religion, not a state, after all, that gave all of mankind the Golden Rule to “do unto others as you would be done by.” Surely that is the pursuit of the common good par excellence. The onus should therefore be on Quebec to prove Loyola’s MWR was failing to meet objectives that were already Catholic objectives before they were Quebec’s objectives.

The replacement of the Catholicism-friendly MWR with the Catholicism-banalizing ERC is not, as the Court of Appeal claims, the imposition of a pedagogical curriculum like any other. It is the abrogation of the Charter provision for freedom of religion, and sets a disquieting precedent for other faith-based corporations. The lower-court justice was correct: Quebec’s position smacks of totalitarianism. The Court of Appeal ruling should not, and hopefully will not stand.




Soutenons les familles dans leurs combats juridiques (reçu fiscal pour tout don supérieur à 50 $)

lundi 10 décembre 2012

Vatican Radio : Catholic School in Quebec loses religious freedom case

ROME — A Catholic private school is considering petitioning the Supreme Court of Canada, after the Quebec Court of Appeal issued a decision obliging it to teach a state-imposed Ethics and Religious Culture course (ERC) at odds with Catholic teaching. The Quebec court issued its decision Dec. 4, overturning an earlier judgment of the Superior Court, which supported the request Loyola High School put to the education minister to teach the course objectives from a Catholic perspective. The Jesuit boys school, located in Montreal, has been battling the provincial government on this issue since 2008.


Marie Bourque, vice-president of the Catholic Parents Association of Quebec, said the decision infringes on the rights of parents to choose an education for their children in line with their faith and values and “to rely on the collaboration of confessional schools” to this end. The Catholic Civil Rights League also issued a comment in agreement.

Bourque described the ERC as a “totally superficial, folkloric and materialistic” program, which “forbids any chronological or historical teaching of religions.”

“It presents them as the fruit of the human mind,” she explained. “It’s all relativistic; there’s no absolute truth at all. So, moral and philosophical stands, which are atheistic, certainly sound more credible than any religion at all in this context.”

Both the Catholic Church and the UN Declaration of Human Rights state that parental rights in education are essential and must be upheld, she underlined.

“The responsibility belongs to (parents) to teach morals and religion. They can delegate it to whom they choose but it belongs absolutely to them in the first place,” she said.

Loyola High School first took legal action in 2008, when the education minister refused to grant equivalency to the school’s Morals and World Religions course. The minister argued that Loyola’s course is taught from a Catholic viewpoint, whereas the state course requires religions to be taught from a secular and religiously neutral perspective.


Listen to the interview by Laura Ieraci with Marie Bourque: RealAudioMP3


See also


Supreme Court — Break with Common Law Putting the Onus on Parents rather than the State(With sample activities and material used in ERC classes)





Soutenons les familles dans leurs combats juridiques (reçu fiscal pour tout don supérieur à 50 $)

lundi 14 septembre 2009

Cheering Big Brother dangerous

By John Carpay, Calgary Sun, 2009-09-13


Columnist Michael Platt incorrectly claims some parents in Québec want to keep their children ignorant about other religions. ("Pinheaded? Believe it," Sept. 6.)

In August [on the 31st] , the Québec Superior Court rejected the demand of parents to exempt their children from a course called "Ethics and Religious Culture" (ERC).

In 2008, this course became mandatory for all students from Grades 1 to 11. Before the ERC course was imposed on public and private religious schools, children in Québec were already being taught about other religions. But parents had a choice to enroll their children in Catholic or Protestant religious instruction – or non-religious moral instruction. Parents objected to the removal of this choice, which triggered the court action. Québec's parents are not against their kids learning about the world's religions. Rather, parents went to court because the course trivializes religion as mere folklore and teaches the relativist notion that there is no truth. It is also opposed by the Québec Secular Movement, because it violates the freedom of conscience of atheists and agnostics who don't want their children presented with religious information they're not equipped to handle. Children are not all the same. Some children can learn about sensitive topics like religion and sexuality at an earlier age than others.

Why should politicians and bureaucrats have the right to determine the age at which all children will be forcibly exposed to facts and ideas about sex and religion? Shouldn't parents be able to determine what information goes into the minds of their own children, and at what age, and how it's taught?

Platt's "government-knows-best" attitude has existed as long as modern public education. Prussia in the 19th century was the first country to force children ages five to 13 to follow a national curriculum to instill respect for authority and following orders. Prussia's goal was to produce obedient citizens who would understand the King is always just and right. As German philosopher Johann Gottlieb Fichte said: "The schools must fashion the person, and fashion him in such a way that he simply cannot will otherwise than what you wish him to will."

Dictators through history have tried to use a mandatory curriculum to impose their ideology on youth. This is why the Universal Declaration of Human Rights affirms the prior right of parents to choose the education given to their children. Parental rights are one of the cornerstones for preserving a free and democratic society. Family autonomy and freedom of conscience are rights that protect atheists and agnostics as much as religious people from government coercion and intrusion. Few things are more coercive and intrusive than Big Brother imposing its ideology on your kids, teaching them the opposite of what you teach at home — especially when it comes to religion and sex.

Platt accuses parents in Québec and Alberta of being "willfully ignorant" zealots for not wanting other people's sexual and religious values imposed on their children. If Platt wants to educate his children in his beliefs (be they religious, secular, agnostic, atheist, progressive, traditionalist or relativist) he should be entitled to do so. But insisting his own attitudes towards religion and sex be imposed on all children through the public education system is just plain wrong. It's always tempting to cheer for Big Brother when he imposes your values on other people. But once Big Brother acquires that right, nothing stops him from imposing other people's values on you.